I realized shortly after wrapping up this review that Nancy had already reviewed this graphic novel in April. Read her post here!
Joe Sacco travels to the Mackenzie River Valley in northwestern Canada. This is where the indigenous peoples called the Dené have lived for generations. This is also where mining and fracking have taken place, as the area is rich in natural resources. The Dené, and other peoples indigenous to the area, have challenged treaties in order to officially have the land recognized as theirs, even as the mining and fracking are taking place and creating jobs that are otherwise hard to come by.
Through mainly interviews, and a little bit of historical research, Sacco presents a work that successfully presents both sides of a sticky issue. The presentation is interesting in that it’s heavy in both journalistic and oral history elements. Much of the testimony is from in-person interviews and storytelling, which is an important part of the Dené culture. What Sacco does is weave these interviews and stories with history and his own observations. It does make for dense reading, even if it’s in graphic novel form.
The art style is no-nonsense. Care is taken to render both the scenery and characters in a realistic manner. Clean cross-hatching is used for the shading. Though it’s nice to look at and study on a technical level, it somehow feels sterile and dry. I suppose that has to do with the subject matter, but a little more personality in the art would have been welcome in order to make the interviewees come to life.
Though the storytelling and art are a technical marvel, I personally felt there was heart and soul missing from this very real story about very real people. I agree with Nancy that this would be an excellent resource to use in the classroom.
Sacco, Joe. Paying the Land. 2020.
November 28, 2020 at 6:59 pm
I am a high school English teacher. So, I am always looking for different reading sources for my students. So you recommend this novel.
Gary On Mon, Nov 23, 2020 at 10:30 AM Graphic Novelty² wrote:
> Kathleen posted: ” I realized shortly after wrapping up this review that > Nancy had already reviewed this graphic novel in April. Read her post here! > Joe Sacco travels to the Mackenzie River Valley in northwestern Canada. > This is where the indigenous peoples called the D” >
LikeLiked by 1 person
December 5, 2020 at 11:07 am