This movie was released to coincide with the Star Trek franchise’s 50th anniversary, and I felt that it was a just a place holder and not a block buster. While I definitely enjoyed it, especially the ending, I’m not sure I will remember the villains or the plot years from now which had become a problem with the TNG movies.
The Good:
A funny opening scene with Kirk trying to flex his diplomatic skills, and basically failing.
The interactions between Kirk, Spock & Bones and the different parings of characters on the planet Altamid.
Sulu’s husband and daughter are shown, which is supposed to be a shout out to George Takei and an acknowledgement there should be more LGBTQ representation in the Trek universe.
Star Base Yorktown was beautifully rendered. I always like seeing crowd scenes in Trek movies and how they represent humans and aliens from all over the universe. Love the costumes!
I liked the stranded Jaylah. She had spunk.
The soundtrack of Beastie Boys and Public Enemy! I liked the line that it was “old fashioned” music.
Great special effects showing the battling ships with the massive swarm of small ships attacking Enterprise.
I liked the picture that Spock looks at of the crew of TOS when going through old Spock’s belongings. Nice tribute to the cast that started this phenomenon! ♥
The Meh:
The villain Krall (even though I just saw this movie this weekend I had to Google the villain’s name). I liked the explanation of who he was originally and his thought process, but that plot didn’t hold up completely. The way he acquired energy from others to extend his life was murky, and how it altered his appearance, I can only guess at.
There was a whole “suspension of disbelief” that a whole star ship would risk all the ship’s crew to do a rescue mission in a nebula that would make them out of touch with the Federation. Realistically, they should have sent a smaller ship and crew.
The Bad:
Knowing this would be the last time we’d see Anton’s portrayal of Chekov. I heard they will not recast him in the next movie, so I wonder what the explanation will be for his absence from future Star Trek films. At least Anton/Chekov’s last portrayal showed him being an integral part of the action and saving the crew.
Uhura’s lack of storyline and that the romance between her and Spock was reduced. They had no chemistry in this outing, despite having great sparks in the first movie. I totally was shipping them, now not so much. I still have hope…
They could have done so much more with Sulu’s supposed same sex marriage. The relationship is merely implied, the poor guy portraying his “husband” had no lines and there should have been a kiss between the two to confirm the relationship.
The motorcycle?? Come on.
While I really liked Jaylah, her backstory took away from potential character development of characters such as Uhura, Chevok, Sulu and Scotty.
But all in all, a very solid Star Trek movie that will guarantee the movie’s future production in the years to come and beyond!
Live long and prosper.
-Nancy
August 18, 2016 at 6:56 am
Nice review , yet to see this movie since i couldn’t find time to go watch it while it was still playing at a theatre near me , now awaiting Blu-rays to be released.
What are your thoughts on Sulu being made a Gay Character? Takei had for years said he wanted for more LGBT characters but he was very unhappy that Sulu was made a Gay Character , He said he didn’t like the idea that they changed a character , he wanted instead new characters to be bought on who were gay instead http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/george-takei-reacts-gay-sulu-909154
LikeLiked by 1 person
August 18, 2016 at 6:25 pm
I was thrilled that the movie made Sulu gay. There needed to be some representation of the LGBTQ community, and what better character than Sulu. We know he had a daughter but never met a wife, so not only did this storyline stay true to Trek canon, but it honored George Takei. I was disappointed at GT’s reply, for if indeed another unknown character was revealed as gay, it wouldn’t have meant much. This way people already “knew” a character and thought highly of them with his/her sexuality not being an issue- as should happen in real life too. Simon Pegg had an excellent rebuttal to Takei’s criticism: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/jul/08/simon-pegg-defends-gay-sulu-after-george-takei-criticism I actually wish they had made the relationship between the two men more certain by them kissing, or having some dialogue that confirmed it, for the ambiguity was a bit of a let down.
LikeLike
August 22, 2016 at 2:32 pm
Good review!
U’ve been invited to th party!:
https://bradscribe.wordpress.com/2016/08/20/the-bradscribe-beach-party/
U can chill out and listen to some “old fashioned” music 😉
Cheers!
LikeLiked by 1 person