Last month I participated in a Zoom book club with my two friends Michael from My Comic Relief and Jeff from The Imperial Talker to discuss the Star Wars book, The High Republic: Light of the Jedi. We all are fans of Star Wars to differing degrees and have loved the recent series The Acolyte. But our discussion took an interesting turn to discuss why we each had a different number one fandom- Jeff ‘s is Star Wars, Mike’s is Doctor Who, and mine is Star Trek. All are sci-fi classics, dating back decades, but all three have different feels to them. So the question is why do I love Star Trek so much?
I am from Generation X, so I hit that sweet spot where I was aware of The Orginal Series television show that I would occasionally watch on re-runs and watched the movies as a child in the theatre. I was dimly aware of The Animated Series but didn’t watch it until I was an adult during the Covid lockdown. I enjoyed the franchise more than kids my age, but was a bigger fan of the original trilogy of Star Wars at the time. But then, dah-dah-dah…The Next Generation began and I was in love! TNG bridged my high school and college years, but I typically associate it more with my college days because that is when I started to share my love for it with my friends. I have to admit, while I was in high school I was trying too hard to be cool and didn’t want to risk talking about Star Trek and being branded weird, but in college, I came into my own. Despite many being surprised that a sorority girl was a Trekkie, I couldn’t stop talking about it. I’m happy to say my friends (and my awesome husband-to-be!) were very supportive of my nerd tendencies and would even buy me Star Trek books or socks with the logo.
So let me discuss why Star Trek is my favorite! Of the three franchises, Star Wars has always been the cooler and most popular of the three, while Doctor Who has a British humor that I can’t relate to. I think the most obvious reason I like Star Trek so much is for its vision of the future. Many of the world’s current problems have been solved and now humankind can concentrate on discovering space, leading to the famous quote “to explore strange new worlds; to seek out new life and new civilizations; to boldly go where no man has gone before!” In addition, Star Trek has the most orderly vibe of the three, and because I grew up in a turbulent home, I crave order. While I am far from militaristic, I appreciate a strong hierarchy and chain of command. Han Solo’s rogue escapades or Doctor Who’s whimsical adventures hold no appeal and actually annoy me. I am a very practical woman (despite some quirkiness) so having a strong framework is a plus for me. But it absolutely is the hope, unity and embrace of exploration and peace that makes me love Star Trek so much.

My thoughts on the entire franchise:
The Original Series 1966-1969 + six movies 1979-1991- I have to give TOS props for starting the franchise. The three seasons delved into some deep issues of the 1960s and the movies started out lame but improved with The Wrath of Khan and The Voyage Home.
The Animated Series 1973-1974- This series is rather cringe-worthy with horrible animation, but there were actually a few strong episodes. I’m glad that I binge-watched this gem.
The Next Generation 1987-1994 + four movies 1994-2002- This is the series that truly made me a fan! I loved the cast and this era is what saved the franchise and let it live on. I liked the interplay and character development and admired the friendship that developed between Doctor Beverly Crusher and Counselor Deanna Troi. During this run, is when I turned my boyfriend (now husband) into a Trekkie too!
Deep Space Nine 1993-1999- DS9 changed up the setup of a crew traveling on a ship and instead gave them a space station that aliens came to. This series developed some very dark stories and tried arc storylines vs episodic storylines.
Voyager 1995-2001- The 1990s was the best time to be a Trekkie! Star Trek’s first woman captain was the indomitable Kathryn Janeway. Stranded far away, she brought her crew home.
Enterprise 2001-2005- A prequel set in the 2150s, this series proved to be lackluster to me, with no characters that truly stood out, and I gave up early in the third season. I viewed it as my least favorite series until Discovery debuted…
Reboot films (Kelvin timeline)- three movies 2009-2016- Chris Pine as Captain Kirk was divine! I liked how they rebooted the franchise but gave them a different timeline so they didn’t contradict existing canon. I so shipped the romance between Spock and Uhura, although I never would have paired them in TOS. The actor who portrayed Chevok sadly died in real life, and while there has been talk for years of giving these movies a fourth and final outing, I find it unlikely as the cast is aging out of their characters and have acting commitments elsewhere. But it was good while it lasted!
Discovery 2017-2024- After a large gap between television series, I was very excited for Discovery to begin but almost immediately disliked it. And then the dislike grew into hate. Critics blasted it for being too woke and not Trekky enough, and while I don’t want to associate myself with haters, I had to agree. Nevertheless, it’s okay not to love everything about a franchise. There are some Star Wars movies or tv series that fans have not liked, and some of the doctors in Doctor Who are more liked than others.
Short Treks 2018-2020- These were fun short episodes that were only a few minutes long and connected to either Discovery or the new upcoming Picard series. I wish they did more of these.
Picard 2020-2023- The cast from TNG reunites in season three! The first two seasons were rather meh, but S3 was fantastic. I hope it leads to a Legacy series that could incorporate cast from TNG, DS9 and Voyager. Please make it so!
Lower Decks 2020-ongoing- I watched a few episodes of this animated series that concentrates on the low-ranking officers vs the captain and senior officers, but I found one of the main characters annoying and gave up on it. But I heard it has gotten better, so I might give it another try.
Prodigy 2021-2024 (ongoing?)- This series is geared toward a younger generation and is also animated with a young motley crew that is helped by a hologram of Captain Janeway. On the brink of cancellation, it might not get a third season. I’ve only watched one episode that incorporated characters from other series. This is a series that I also might backtrack and watch.
Strange New Worlds 2022-ongoing- I love this new series, as it returns to episodic storytelling like TOS. It is a prequel about Captain Pike, who directly preceded Captain Kirk. The TOS crew is slowly being introduced, we meet a young Spock and Uhura right away and have recently met Scotty and Kirk before he was a captain. They are having fun with the episodes and are trying out lots of different styles of storytelling. Plus Pike is dreamy!
Section 31 Movie 2025- A spin-off from Discovery with the amazing Michelle Yeoh, but I don’t have high hopes for the made-for-TV movie. She will be portraying a secret operative from the shadowy Section 31 that is on the fringes of the Federation.
Starfleet Academy 2025 or 2026- Another spinoff from Discovery that will be set in the far future of the 32nd Century when the Federation is re-establishing itself. It has some intriguing names set to star in it, but I am very leery of the tone of the series since it is spun off from my least favorite series.
58 years strong at this point, Star Trek shows no signs of ending. The showrunners are aware they have an aging fanbase and are trying different types of series and attempting to win over new fans. I admire this dedication, for the franchise needs to continue to grow and evolve, just like the future utopia that creator Gene Roddenberry imagined. That Star Trek has stayed with me through different decades of my life, as I too have grown and changed, is a credit to the excellence of the Star Trek universe. Live Long and Prosper my friends!










Recent Comments